Columns

If you use metal detectors, don't go it alone

Understanding your equipment's capabilities up front keeps food safe and makes manufacturing easier.

Richard F. Stier
In the last few years, I've been in many plants and have seen staff fighting more than one battle with the facility's metal detectors. In each of these cases, the problems stemmed from the plant trying to commission and/or operate the metal detector on its own. But the time, effort and aggravation experienced by plant staff could have been alleviated with a single call to the equipment vendor.



Metal detection has become an integral part of most food processing operations. In fact, many companies mandate every ingredient they buy must be run through a metal detection system. This business practice can protect raw materials, finished goods and your brand.

But how do you choose the right metal detector? They may be used to detect metal in liquid systems, powders that flow, pieces of meat, fruit or vegetables and packaged products. To select the right tool for the right application, processors must understand not only their products but also the capabilities of metal detection technology.

The very nature of some products can cause a metal detector to reject them and interfere with the detector's sensitivity. Products that may cause this kind of reaction-known as a "product effect"-are those with high moisture content such as meat, cheese, warm bread, fresh produce and most liquids. The detector can be adjusted to minimize this effect, but its achievable sensitivity will be reduced.

Low-moisture products such as cookies, fried snacks, sugars and cereals have little product effect and can operate at greater sensitivities. Frozen foods also have little product effect since their moisture is bound up.



To select the right tool for the right application, processors must understand not only their products but also the capabilities of metal detection technology. Source: Thermo Electron.
Processors can come up against challenges when they try to install detectors on their own. For example, one company decided to run all of its finished products through a metal detector. This processor manufactured a wide range of products (300 SKUs) and decided to pass cased goods through the detector prior to palletizing. The processor's client had standards of 1.0 mm for ferrous and 1.5 mm for non-ferrous. The processor unsuccessfully tried to make the unit work for the standards. When the processor finally called the metal detector company, the service representative said the unit simply could not run at the desired sensitivities. The rep sent a letter describing the minimum operating parameters for the unit given the products the processor was running. The processor shared the letter with its client, who granted a waiver to operate at lower sensitivities for its products.

In another example, a processor decided to install a metal detector on a line handling sauces with particulates. The processor did the set-up on its own and adjusted the sensitivities to the lowest possible detection limit. This operation also had problems. With the supplier's help, the processor adjusted the sensitivity upward and made changes to the software, solving the problems.

With metal detection becoming mandatory, processors must do everything they can to get their systems working properly from the very beginning. This means understanding products and the basic principles of metal detection and taking advantage of the expertise offered by suppliers. Remember one of the primary corollaries to Murphy's Law: "There is never time to do it right, but there is always time to do it again."

Richard-stiers
Richard Stier is a consulting food scientist who has helped food processors develop safety, quality and sanitation programs. He believes in emphasizing the importance of how these programs can help companies increase profits. Stier holds degrees in food science from Rutgers University and the University of California at Davis. He is a Contributing Editor for Food Engineering. Email: rickstier4@aol.com

Recent Articles by Richard Stier, Contributing Editor

You must register or login in order to post comments.

Multimedia

Videos

Image Galleries

Frito-Lay Casa Grande Gallery

Frito-Lay Casa Grande was chosen as Food Engineering's 2011Sustainable Plant of the Year.Part learning lab, part sustainability showcase, the Frito-Lay facility in Casa Grande is the focus of the snack food manufacturer’s ambitious goal of creating a blueprint for sustained production in a resource-strapped tomorrow.

05/25/11 2:00 PM EDT

Seven Surprising Uses for Spray Technology

On-Demand: Processors clean, coat, cool, dry, and lubricate products and equipment in dozens of areas in a plant thousands of times a year. Even though it may not be obvious, spray technology is often the backbone of these operations and can be used in many more.

THE MAGAZINE

Food Engineering Magazine

may 2012 cover

2012 May

Check out Food Engineering's May issue!!
TABLE OF CONTENTS SUBSCRIBE

THE FOOD ENGINEERING STORE

Package-Design-Workbook
Package Design Workbook: The Art and Science of Successful Packaging

The book will address all aspects of the creative process including choosing a package format, colors and materials, final finishes, and special considerations such as awkward objects and unique display conderations.

More Products

Clear Seas Research

Clear Seas ResearchWith access to over one million professionals and more than 60 industry-specific publications,Clear Seas Research offers relevant insights from those who know your industry best. Let us customize a market research solution that exceeds your marketing goals.

Food Master

Food MasterFood Master 2012 is now available!

Where the buying process begins in the food and beverage manufacturing market. 

Visit www.foodmaster.com to learn more.

STAY CONNECTED

Facebook Twitter  logo YouTube